The Sober Truth: Debunking the Bad Science Behind 12-Step Programs and the Rehab Industry
An exposé of Alcoholics nameless, 12-step courses, and the rehab industry—and how a failed addiction-treatment version got here to dominate America.
AA has turn into so infused in our society that it truly is virtually synonymous with dependancy restoration. but the facts exhibits that AA has just a 5–10 percentage luck rate—hardly higher than no therapy in any respect. regardless of this, medical professionals, employers, and judges frequently refer addicted humans to remedy courses and rehab amenities in keeping with the 12-step model.
In The Sober Truth, acclaimed habit professional Dr. Lance Dodes exposes the deeply unsuitable technology that the 12-step has used to aid its courses. Dr. Dodes analyzes dozens of reports to bare a startling development of mistakes, misjudgments, and biases. He additionally pores over the examine to spotlight the easiest peer-reviewed stories to be had and discovers that they achieve a grim consensus at the program’s total success.
But The Sober Truth is greater than a publication approximately dependancy. it's also a publication approximately technological know-how and the way and why AA and rehab turned so well known, regardless of the discouraging facts. Dr. Dodes explores the whole tale of AA’s upward thrust, from its origins in early fundamentalist non secular and mystical ideals to its present-day position of privilege in politics and media.
The Sober Truth contains actual tales from Dr. Dodes’s thirty-five years of scientific perform, in addition to firsthand debts submitted by way of addicts via an open invitation at the Psychology Today site. those tales vividly demonstrate the adventure of strolling the stairs and attending the various nation’s most renowned rehabilitation facilities.
The Sober Truth builds a robust reaction to the monopoly of the 12-step software and explodes the parable that those courses supply a suitable or common way to the deeply own challenge of dependancy. This book offers new and actionable info for addicts, their households, and clinical services, and lays out greater how one can comprehend dependancy for these looking a more suitable and compassionate method of this treatable problem.
From the Hardcover edition.
AA attendees and “treatment” staff: within the first yr . . . 273 (59.2%) of the 461 members entered specialist therapy and 269 (58.4%) entered AA. within the moment and 3rd years of follow-up, 167 members (36.2%) have been in remedy and 176 (38.2%) participated in AA. In years four to eight, a hundred and forty four members (31.2%) have been in remedy and 166 (36.0%) participated in AA.20 Unsurprisingly, they discovered that the folk who caught with both treatment—AA or expert treatment—did considerably.
opposite arthritis, for example, it’s no longer sufficient to show that thirteen to fifty five percentage of individuals providing with undifferentiated arthritis skilled a regression of the sickness while given the drug: undifferentiated arthritis reverses by itself at accurately that rate.38 diversified diagnoses have diversified levels of spontaneous remission. In pancreatic melanoma, spontaneous remission is rare. For colds and flus, spontaneous remission is the norm. the load of facts for any “cure” is to teach.
in part actual, yet I’m right here to paintings on that stuff, to not get crushed up approximately it. besides, I did the twenty-eight days . . . and that i fairly loved assembly the folks there. Even the nurses’ aides have been striking men to speak to. in order that used to be strong. . . . yet i may by no means particularly hook into the NA and AA philosophy. It appeared compelled to me. Oh, and I’ll let you know the opposite factor. I suggest, the medical professionals have been consistently hammering us with an ethical part to drug dependancy. They appeared fairly captivated with faith.
approximately something, then you definately are the individual at fault. when you are harmed by way of another person you then are at fault for being round them, if anything undesirable occurs to then you WHY no longer YOU, you're an alcoholic. I as soon as heard a girl talk about . . . how she learn an amends letter on the grave of a guy who had sexually abused her as a toddler. i used to be very disillusioned through listening to sponsor instructed her to do any such factor. Sponsors frequently act like a few blend of therapist and dad or mum and aren't certified to be a.
reports is not any be sure that the numbers may be handled with no bias or perhaps that they characterize whatever invaluable. As we now have additionally noticeable, the vast majority of habit experiences overlaying 12-step therapy fail to move easy threshold criteria of experimental keep an eye on and causal inference. but those mistaken methodologies should not continually obvious to the lay reviewer, and the click infrequently is helping issues with its ongoing confusion among managed technological know-how and meaningless correlations. therefore, a lot.